Grading AI’s Take on Removing Solder Off a Printed Circuit Board

Posted in Featured Post on by .

With all the hype around AI, we decided to take it up on some common electronics manufacturing questions and then grade it for accuracy. Let’s take a look at how ChatGPT answered the question, “What is the best way to clean solder off a printed circuit board?”.

Cleaning solder off a printed circuit board (PCB) requires careful handling to avoid damaging the components or the board itself. The method you choose depends on the situation and the type of solder you’re dealing with. Here are a few methods you can consider:

1. Solder Wick or Desoldering Braid: This is a commonly used method for removing excess solder from PCBs. Solder wick is a braided copper wire that absorbs molten solder when heated with a soldering iron. Place the wick on the solder joint, apply heat with the iron, and the solder should wick up into the braid. This is effective for small amounts of solder and precision work.

2. Desoldering Pump/Solder Sucker: A desoldering pump or solder sucker is a tool designed to suck up molten solder. It has a plunger mechanism that creates a vacuum when triggered, pulling the liquid solder away from the joint. This method is useful for larger amounts of solder or when you need to quickly remove solder from multiple joints.

3. Hot Air Rework Station: A hot air rework station is a specialized tool that blows hot air onto the solder joint, melting the solder and allowing you to remove the component or clean the joint. This method is particularly useful when you need to remove components from the PCB before cleaning.

4. Soldering Iron and Flux: Apply a small amount of flux to the solder joint and then heat the joint with a soldering iron. As the solder melts, use the iron’s tip to carefully push it off the joint. Be cautious not to apply too much heat for too long, as excessive heat can damage the PCB or components.

5. Chemical Solder Removers: There are commercial solder removers available that can help dissolve solder. These are typically a last resort, as they involve chemicals that can potentially damage the PCB or components if not used properly. Follow the manufacturer’s instructions closely and ensure that the chemical used is safe for the specific materials on your PCB.

Remember these tips when cleaning solder off a PCB:

  • Work in a well-ventilated area
  • Use appropriate safety gear, including safety glasses and heat-resistant gloves
  • Be gentle to avoid damaging the PCB or components
  • Avoid overheating, as excessive heat can damage components, traces, or the PCB itself
  • If you’re inexperienced or unsure, it might be a good idea to practice on a scrap PCB before working on your actual project

Ultimately, the best method for cleaning solder off a PCB depends on your comfort level, the tools you have available, and the specific situation you’re dealing with. If you’re uncertain, it’s always a good idea to seek guidance from experienced individuals or professionals.

Here is our engineer’s take on how ChatGPT did:

The first couple suggestions are typically what I do.

  • Solder wick is really good for cleaning up pads after parts removal. It is great for SMT work but doesn’t work as well for through-hole components. I would have like to see a mention of making sure you continue to use fresh solder wick.
  • The desoldering pump works best for through-hole components. It can be used for SMT work but I would only use it if there was a lot of solder to remove.

The next couple were more for removing components, which are helpful but not really related to removing solder.

The mention of chemical solder removers is dangerous. ChatGPT gave the warnings but I wish it would have left it off the list.

I really like the extra tips that it provided – these are usually assumed or skipped over.

Overall, I think ChatGPT did a great job with this question. Grade B+.